Main Menu

 

Risk Management
IFC and Panhellenic Council's Risk Management Policy
Risk Management Enforcement Procedure
Alcohol Enforcement and Wristband Policy
IFC and Panhellenic - Peer Review Board Constitution
Social and Risk Management Manual
 
 

 

Peer Review Board Constitution
 

Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Association - Peer Review Board Constitution

ARTICLE I: NAME

The name of the judicial bodies of the Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Association shall be the Peer Review Boards.

ARTICLE II: PURPOSE

The Peer Review Boards of the Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Associations will have the responsibility of reviewing cases involving chapters who have been charged in violating Interfraternity and Panhellenic Association or University policies.

1. Fraternity misconduct need not be sanctioned by the entire membership in order to be considered grounds for disciplinary action taken against the entire chapter.

2. A complaint may be considered a matter of referral to the Peer Review Board whenever the actions of fraternity members could reasonably be expected to reflect negatively upon, or cause conflict within the Greek community.

3. Complaints will be categorized as risk management violations or conduct violations.

4. The IFC or Panhellenic Association Vice President for Internal Affairs will adjudicate all violations respectively for their organizations.

5. The Vice President for Internal Affairs will review all charges filed with the Peer Review Board and will recommend that the Community Judicial Board adjudicate violations which the board may not be able to competently adjudicate or which seriously violate University policy or the laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.

ARTICLE III: MEMBERSHIP

The membership of the Peer Review Boards will consist of the following persons:

1. The Peer Review Boards shall be presided over by the Vice President for Internal Affairs respectively of the IFC and Panhellenic Association for all hearings.

2. If the Vice President for Internal Affairs is unable to attend a hearing, the Vice President for External Affairs (Panhellenic Association) or Vice President for Activities (Interfraternity Council) will preside over the hearing.

3. Voting members shall be comprised of the members of the respective Executive Boards of the IFC and/or Panhellenic Association.

ARTICLE IV: DUTIES OF MEMBERS

A. Duties of Judicial Chair (Vice President for Internal Affairs)

1. Receive and review all cases pertaining to violations of the IFC and Panhellenic Constitutions, any policy enacted by the Interfraternity and Panhellenic Associations, or violations of University policy.
2. Schedule all meetings and hearings.
3. Provide appropriate evidentiary materials.
4. Preside over all Peer Review Board hearings.
5. Call board to order.
6. Conduct hearing.
7. Announce final decision.
8. Adjourn the board.
9. Keep all matters related to Peer Review Board hearings confidential.

B. Duties of Board Members

1. Attend all Peer Review Board training sessions.
2. Hear and decide all cases brought before the Peer Review Board.
3. Keep all matters related to Peer Review Board hearings confidential.

ARTICLE V: POWERS

A. The Peer Review Board has the power to: (1) arbitrate and mediate cases, (2) impose and/or recommend sanctions in cases involving the following:

Sanctions may be imposed in cases dealing with:

1. Violations of any Interfraternity and Panhellenic Association policies.
2. Violations of University policy when referred by the University’s judicial administrator.
3. Grievances brought forth by a member chapter against another member chapter.

ARTICLE VI: CODE OF RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES

A. The following rules apply to member chapters, new members, guests, visitors, and alumni.

B. All hearings shall be governed by the "Statement of Value and Ethics of the Bucknell Community" which will consist of the following: Constitution of the Interfraternity Council; any policy enacted by the Interfraternity Council, any Bucknell University policy, or any item the Peer Review Board determines to be of importance to maintaining the harmony of the Greek system.

C. Prescribed conduct of member organizations:

1. Disruption of Greek authorized activities.
2. Intentional infliction or threat of bodily harm:
a. Intentionally inflicting bodily harm on any person while on Greek premises.
b. Taking any action with reckless disregard that bodily harm could result upon any person instigated on Greek premises; or threatened use of force to inflict bodily harm on any person while on Greek premises.
3. Intentional Destruction of Property: Intentionally damaging, destroying, or defacing of Greek property or property of any person while on Greek premises.
4. Theft of Property: Theft of Greek property or property of any person while on Greek premises.
5. Forcible entrance into any building or structure on Greek premises.
6. Unauthorized alteration or use of fire fighting equipment, safety devices, or other emergency or safety equipment.
7. Negligent Infliction or Threat of Bodily Harm:
a. Failure to exercise reasonable care, thereby creating a substantial risk to any person while on Greek premises.
8. Violation of Hazing and Pre-Initiation policies

9. Repetitions of Misconduct: A chapter who is found guilty of conduct prescribed or fails to comply with the sanctions of this code shall be subject to the maximum sanction of dismissal or any lesser sanction authorized by this code if found guilty for which the sanction imposed was dismissal, suspension, or Greek Disciplinary Probation.

ARTICLE VII: HEARING PROCEDURES

A. The Peer Review Board hearing procedures should be attached to the Interfraternity Council and Panhellenic Association Constitutions and be reviewed annually.

B. Preliminary:

1. The Vice President for Internal Affairs will review the case and retain the right to dismiss the case at that point.
2. The Vice President for Internal Affairs will immediately provide written notification of charges pending to the President of the accused organization. Written notification may be transmitted via University e-mail.
3. Any member of the University community may charge that a fraternity has violated an Interfraternity or Panhellenic Association regulation or a University policy.
a. Charges can be filed based on a violation of the University or IFC or Panhellenic Association policies concerning the consumption of alcohol, the risk management policy, the policy concerning hazing and pre-initiation activities, and/or any policy governing or affecting Greek Life.
b. The University may press charges on behalf of a member of the University community or, if it is the injured party, on the behalf of the institution.
4. The charges are to be filed in writing to the Vice President for Internal Affairs.
5. The hearing date will be arranged by the Vice President for Internal Affairs. He will notify all involved parties, in writing, of the date, time, and location of the hearing. Notification may be made via University e-mail.
6. A minimum notice of five (5) business days is to be given to the involved party of the charges prior to the hearing date.
7. Upon the request of the accused fraternity, a delay of the formal hearing by the Peer Review Board of up to five (5) days from the time of the receipt of the Statement of Charges may occur. In addition, the Peer Review Board and the accused may agree to a delay of more than five (5) days. However, if not agreed upon the hearing must take place within five (5) days or at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the IFC or Panhellenic Association Executive Board.

a. The fraternity shall not be on probation or suffer any sanctions while they wait for a committee hearing (including appeals) unless the fraternity agrees to the suggested sanction (the fraternity decides to plead guilty), or would like to have the option of time served.

C. Procedures at the Hearing

1. Peer Review Board Chair shall brief all involved parties on procedures of the hearing.
2. In a case where a board member's chapter is involved, that member shall remove himself from that case.
3. The parties involved have the right to call witnesses on their behalf.
4. The parties involved have the right to have an advisor (faculty, staff, chapter, etc.) present during the hearing. The advisor may not be an attorney, nor may the advisor present evidence, introduce motions, or speak on behalf of or for the organization. His or her role is solely to advise the fraternity.
5. The Chair shall read the charges brought against the defendant.
6. The Peer Review Board shall be given the opportunity to present the evidence first..
7. The chapter shall be given the opportunity to present their case.
8. Members of the board shall have the opportunity to question the IFC Vice President for Internal Relations and chapter and witnesses. Only questions of clarification or "points of information" will be permitted.
9. The parties involved shall leave the room and the board shall discuss the case under the supervision of the Chair.
10. Immediately following deliberations a vote shall be taken to determine guilt or innocence.
a. A quorum shall consist of 2/3 of the Executive Board members comprising the IFC or Panhellenic Association. There must be quorum to conduct business and to conduct a vote.
b. In the case of a vote, a simple majority shall rule.
c. Board members may vote guilty, not guilty, or abstain.
d. The chairperson shall vote in the case of a tie.
11. After a verdict is reached, the board will determine the sanctions to be levied in the case of a guilty verdict.
12. When all business is concluded the parties involved will be notified verbally, by the Vice President for Internal Relations, within 24 hours, and in writing within 48 hours, by the Secretary, of the results of the hearing.
13. The Vice President for Internal Affairs will notify the Assistant Dean of Students verbally within 24 hours of the decision of the Peer Review Board.
14. The Vice President for Internal Affairs will notify the organization of the final appeal procedure.
15. The Chair will adjourn the hearing.

E. Appeals

1. Appeals may be submitted, in writing, to the Assistant Dean of Students, and must be submitted within five (5) days of the date of the hearing.
a. An appeal may request that sanctions be reduced or eliminated as a result of one of the following conditions:
1. Lack of substantial basis and fact to support sanction.
2. Incongruity of sanction.
3. Alleged unfairness in procedures.
4. Newly discovered, important evidence, not known at the time of the hearing.

Article VIII: DISCIPLINARY RIGHTS

1. An accused fraternity scheduled to appear before the Peer Review Board of the Interfraternity Council will be afforded the following procedural rights:

a. A written statement in advance of the hearing indicating the nature and basis of the charge(s) obtained by the Executive Board. This written statement may be transmitted electronically via e-mail.
b. Upon request of the accused fraternity, a delay of the formal hearing by the Peer Review Board of up to five (5) days from the time of receipt of the Statement of Charges may occur. In addition, the Peer Review Board and the accused may agree to a delay of more than five (5) days. However, if not agreed upon the hearing must take place within five (5) days or at the next regularly scheduled meeting of the IFC Executive Board acting as the Peer Review Board.
c. The fraternity shall not be on probation or suffer any sanctions while they wait for a committee hearing (including appeals) unless the fraternity agrees to the suggested sanction, the fraternity decides to plead guilty, or would like to have the option of time served.
d. To challenge for cause any member of the Peer Review Board. Such challenge(s) must be made in writing to the Vice President for Internal Affairs of the Interfraternity Council. The decision of the Vice President for Internal Affairs with regard to the challenge will be final.
e. To be judged only on evidence relevant to the charge(s) presented at the hearing.
f. To be assisted by the faculty or alumni advisor during the hearing.
g. To be advised of the evidence against the fraternity, to have an opportunity to rebut adverse testimony, and to question witnesses.
h. To present evidence and witnesses relevant to the charge.
i. To decline to appear at the hearing with the understanding that the case will be considered in the fraternity's absence.
j. To decline to answer questions which might tend to be self-incriminating. (Refusal to do so shall not be considered evidence of guilt.)
k. To be given written notification of the decision.
l. To be advised of the reasons for the decision, if requested.
m. To request, within one (1) week of the decision of the Peer Review Board, a review of the case which will result in a re-hearing if one or more of the following conditions is established to the satisfaction of either of the reviewing authorities:

1. All relevant evidence has not been introduced.
2. New evidence or information has become available.
4. Procedural error - a guaranteed element of due process was abridged or omitted.
5. To have three levels of review:

a. The Peer Review Board.
b. The Assistant Deans of Students
c. The Dean of Students.

2. A record of the offense and the sanction imposed against the fraternity will remain on file in the Office of the Deans of Students and with the Vice President for Internal Affairs of the IFC.

Article IX: SANCTIONS

1. The following sanctions will be assigned by the IFC Peer Review Board to a chapter found to be in violation of the IFC and Panhellenic Risk Management Policy. Sanction levels are cumulative and are not cleared until the end of the semester. All fines are due within ten (10) business days or an additional fee of $50.00 per business day is added to the total sanction.

Wristband Log Offenses:

first offense if under 5 log violations: warning
1 - 5 log violations: $ 50.00 fine
6 – 10 log violations: $ 100.00 fine
11 or more violations: $ 150.00 fine

Unregistered Social Events:

first offense: $ 200.00 fine
second offense: $ 400.00 fine
third offense: $ 1,000.00 fine and probation for remainder of semester.

Underage Alcohol Possession or Consumption:

first offense: $ 100.00 per individual
second offense: $ 150.00 per individual
third offense: $ 200.00 per individual
subsequent violations: $300.00 per individual

Kegs: all offenses:

$ 500.00 per keg

Miscellaneous Risk Management Policy Violations (these include failure to provide beer tickets/cards, failure to provide adequate food and alternate beverages, failure to provide TIPS certification cards or proof of TIPS certification at the time requested, failure to post State sign at bar regarding the legal age for alcohol consumption, failure to have the appropriate number of individuals working assigned stations, etc.)

first offense: $ 50.00 fine per risk management violation
second offense: $ 100.00 fine per risk management violation
third offense: $ 200.00 fine per risk management violation
fourth and subsequent offenses: $ 300.00 fine per risk management violation

Example: If a chapter is found responsible for the following violation: (1) no alternate food or beverages available, and (2) front door not staffed by two TIPS certified members. And if these are the chapter’s first violations of the year, the fine would be $50.00 per violations for a total of $100.00.

NOTE: Eight (8) offenses of any kind or an accumulation of $ 750.00 in fines will result in automatic social probation for thirty (30) academic days.

1. There is a right of appeal from the IFC Peer Review Board. Appeal from the Peer Review Board is to the Assistant Dean of Students. Decisions of the Appeals Board will rescind, revise, or modify the action of the Peer Review Board.

2. The Peer Review Board shall have the privilege and right to examine itself as to whether it is qualified to dispose of any case. Should it find itself unqualified it may refer the case to the Community Judicial Board.

3. All money collected from fines shall be used by the IFC to provide educational programs for the Greek system, to provide IFC scholarships, and/or to contribute funds to community service and/or philanthropic programs.

 
Bucknell | Find People | Contact Us
Office of Greek Life at Bucknell University
570-577-1602